Home » Jazz Articles » Album Review » Bill Frisell: All We Are Saying...

Bill Frisell: All We Are Saying...

By Ian Patterson
December 21, 2011
View read count

Thirty-one years after

John Lennon

guitar and vocals
1940 - 1980

" data-original-title="" title="">John Lennon's murder there's no sign of his influence waning. Guitarist Bill Frisell adds personal tribute to the singer/songwriter/activist on All We Are Saying..., the year after vigils and tribute concerts were held to honor Lennon's 70th birthday from Liverpool to New York and everywhere in between. In Iceland, Yoko Ono lit a tulip-shaped beacon of light in the memorial Imagine Peace Tower, which combined with the Northern Lights in spectacular tribute. Frisell's homage is, of course, more subdued, but these heartfelt renditions of Lennon's music reflect long devotion; as Frisell says in the liner notes: "There was nothing we really needed to do to prepare for this. We've been preparing our whole lives."

The project had an unforeseen birth, beginning as a one-off Lennon tribute at a Paris concert in 2005. Frisell was in a trio then, with violinist

Jenny Scheinman

violin
b.1979

" data-original-title="" title="">Jenny Scheinman and steel guitarist Greg Leisz, though apart from one delightful duet between Frisell and Scheinman on "Love," all the selections here feature Frisell's quintet, with drummer

Kenny Wollesen

drums

" data-original-title="" title="">Kenny Wollesen and bassist

Tony Scherr

bass

" data-original-title="" title="">Tony Scherr adding a simple pulse to the music. On more rocked-out tunes like "Revolution" and "Come Together," the strong backbeat and precise bass works well, but Frisell, Scheinman and Leisz dovetail so beautifully throughout that there's a feeling some tunes might have worked better in a more intimate trio setting.

Rather than try to create a sonically challenging, genre-bending reinterpretation of Lennon's music, Frisell presents a straightforward country/rock-flavored set, reflecting the guitarist and his group's love of Lennon's melodies. With one, two or all three of the string-players carrying the melody faithfully, improvisational embellishment is restricted to counterpoint flourishes and arresting harmonics, and fans of Frisell's sometimes more exuberant playing might be disappointed—this is very much a tribute to Lennon's tunes, and not a showcase for virtuosity. The country/roots feel of the music makes this one of the most Americana-flavored of Frisell's body of work, which is perhaps ironic, given the source material originally hails from the English industrial city of Liverpool.

Some of the tunes work better than others, with "Please, Please Me" sounding a little stiff, but slower tunes like "Imagine," "In My Life," "Julia" and "Woman" fully reveal the string interplay at its most empathetic; the passing back and forth of "Across the Universe"'s melody is touching, as though Frisell, Scheinman and Leisz are genuinely sharing an object of rare beauty. The centerpiece—and worth the price of admission—is a gorgeous rendition of "You've Got to Hide Your Love Away," with Frisell's improvisations as seductive as they are succinct. The more guitar-centric "Mother" is a slow-burning blues, while Frisell really shines on "Number 9 Dream," his chords and pearly little peels seeming to pay secondary tribute to

Wes Montgomery

guitar
1923 - 1968

" data-original-title="" title="">Wes Montgomery.

The appropriately inspired closer, "Give Peace a Chance," is imbued with the quietly epic quality that is a Frisell trademark. One of the most elegant Lennon tributes, All We Are Saying... is yet another fine addition to the eclectic Frisell's discography; where will he take us next?

Learn more about our star rating system

Track Listing

Across the Universe; Revolution; Nowhere Man; Imagine; Please Please Me; You've Got to Hide Your Love Away; Hold On; In My Life; Come Together; Julia; Woman; #9 Dream; Love; Beautiful Boy; Mother; Give Peace a Chance.

Personnel

Bill Frisell

guitar, electric

Bill Frisell: guitar; Greg Leisz: steel and acoustic guitars; Jenny Scheinman: violin; Tony Scherr: bass; Kenny Wollesen: drums.

Album information

Title: All We Are Saying... | Year Released: 2011 | Record Label: Savoy Jazz

PREVIOUS / NEXT

R.J. DeLuke's Best Releases of 2011
< Previous

Pipoka Trio with Sam Huber, Helsinki...
Next >

Bill Frisell Concerts

Oct 24 Fri

MELBOURNE INTERNATIONAL JAZZ FESTIVAL :: Bill Frisell...

The Jazzlab
Brunswick, Australia

Nov 21 Fri

Bill Frisell Trio

Cadogan Hall
London, UK

Nov 22 Sat

Bill Frisell Trio

Wiltshire Music Centre
Bradford On Avon, Wiltshire, Ba15 1dz, UK

Mar 27 Fri

Bill Frisell: 75th Birthday Celebration with Special...

The Appel Room
New York, NY

Mar 28 Sat

Bill Frisell: 75th Birthday Celebration with Special...

The Appel Room
New York, NY

Apr 2 Thu

Bill Frisell - In My Dreams

Wexner Center for the Arts
Columbus, OH

Apr 2 Thu

Bill Frisell - In My Dreams

Wexner Center for the Arts
Columbus, OH

Support All About Jazz

All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

Go Ad Free!

To maintain our platform while developing new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity, we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for as little as $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination vastly improves your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.