Home » Jazz Articles » Book Review » Bob Dylan: The Philosophy of Modern Song
Bob Dylan: The Philosophy of Modern Song
Bob Dylan
guitar and vocalsb.1941
Certainly more than a decade-long gestation period is plenty of time to select and finalize the songs, choose the photos and secure the rights to publish, then design the integration of same that is so eye-pleasing. But that process still begs the question of the actual process that the Nobel Laureate used to write these incisive essays along with the more extemporaneous content that often accompanies them: he simultaneously maintains the airs of deeply thoughtful contemplation and abiding spontaneity.
Of course, the mystery arising from the process of authorship for The Philosophy of Modern Song is in keeping with Bob Dylan's body of work as a songwriter, recording artist, live performer and cultural icon. It is not quite fair to say that "nothing is revealed" here, as in "The Ballad of Frankie Lee and Judas Priest" from John Wesley Harding (Columbia, 1968), but the author certainly doesn't explain everything.
There is no foreword or introduction to outline the concept of the book (even though the very last sentence might suffice). Except for a dedication to singer/songwriter

Doc Pomus
composer / conductor1925 - 1991

Little Richard
piano1935 - 2020
The man born Robert Zimmerman is not out to teach either the craft or art of songwriting either. Still, anyone who wants to learn about either or both fields of study has plentiful resources of which to avail themselves here. To declare that Bob Dylan has eclectic taste is a vast understatement and his exposition of it here may widen the readers,' especially as it is combined with a clear exhibition of his command of the subtleties of composition and performance. From his reliably expert point of view, the turn of a vocal phrase can be as significant as the drop or add of a single letter ("Twitchy Woman"?) not to mention the prevailing tone of the vocal (Perry Como's on "Without A Song").
There is little if any doubt that the Minnesota native has heard and thought about these tunes multiple times over the course of his now eighty-one years, so it is little surprise he often examines chosen topics such as Dean Martin's "Blue Moon'' in terms of recordings and performances as the compositions themselves. Yet the scholarly formality is often no deeper than the joyous rediscovery of the subjects at hand, whether it be

Frank Sinatra
vocals1915 - 1998

Little Walter
harmonica1930 - 1968

Willie Nelson
guitar
Elvis Presley
vocals1935 - 1977

Grateful Dead
band / ensemble / orchestrab.1965
The writer studiously maintains his attention on the topics at hand, even as he occasionally digresses into personal opinions, allusions to history and pure flights of fancy just often enough to impart pacing to the succession of chapters; it's a progression not all that dissimilar from that of a well-sequenced album or live performance. The generally healthy, good- humored detachment of the author also adds to the thought-provoking nature of this work.
Then again, amateur or professional psychologists (not to mention the most obsessive of Dylanologists) might well have a field day here. The combination of bile and latent sexism is more than just a little disturbing in the pieces on

Eagles
band / ensemble / orchestrab.1971

Allman Brothers Band
band / ensemble / orchestra
Jackson Browne
guitarb.1948
Needless to say, these veritable Rorschach tests of Dylan's compel repeated readings too. And, not surprisingly, such nuanced observations also lend themselves as readily to casual skimming as more careful perusal of both text and photos. All of which only adds to the potential durability of The Philosophy of Modern Song: likely as not, each successive exposure to its various element will bring something(s) new to mind (hence the wisdom of leaving the roughly seven by nine inch tome readily accessible for impulse examination).
Similar to but ultimately superior to Bob Dylan's aforementioned first book and quite comparable in its distinctive voice to his autobiographical Chronicles Vol. 1 (Simon & Schuster, 2004), this third effort reaffirms the one-time 'voice of a generation's elevated level of creativity over the last twenty-five years. The Philosophy of Modern Song reminds us how fortunate we are to be living at the same time as he.
Tags
Book Review
Bob Dylan
Doug Collette
Simon & Schuster
Jack Kerouac
Doc Pomus
Little Richard
Eddie Cochran
frank sinatra
Little Walter
Elvis Presley
Marty Robbins
Comments
PREVIOUS / NEXT
Support All About Jazz
All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.


The Philosophy of Modern Song 



Buy Now
