Home » Jazz Articles » Live Review » Matana Roberts At Black Box
Matana Roberts At Black Box
ByBlack Box
Belfast, N. Ireland
August 28, 2024
Billed as "Matana Roberts + Guest," this Moving On Music gig turned out to be a solo performance by the Chicago-born, New York-based reeds player and sound experimentalist. No explanation was given as to why the "plus one" failed to show, but it is not as if there are no great improvising musicians in these parts. Still, nobody was complaining, as the chance to see the multi-faceted Roberts solo does not come around too often in Belfast.
The gig came with an air of expectation, not least because of Robert's widely acclaimed Coin Coin series, an ambitious 12-album cycle (up to five at time of writing) that delves deep into the Africa-American experience from slavery onwards, interrogating history, identity and American society. With Coin Coin Roberts has created a unique compositional aesthetic that is part-cultural memory, part-social manifesto. But this gig was a strange affair that did not quite live up to the billing.
Eliciting a hummed drone from the small but attentive audience, Roberts sang a couple of versus of The Meat Puppets' gospel-inspired "Comin' Down." The audience drone was called upon repeatedly throughout the short set, with Roberts seeming to draw on its energy for inspiration. Her muse would lead her into song, brief soprano saxophone improvisations and anecdotal asides aplenty.
Matana intoned the phrase "this is an improvisation" like a mantra at regular intervals, riffing the four words four times, seven times and, on one breathless occasion, seventeen times in succession. Perhaps this was a device used to trigger thoughts or musical ideas, or perhaps it was intended to convince the audience of the improvised nature of the performance. The improvisation lay chiefly in Robert's saxophone solos. Lasting no more than a couple of minutes at a time, these solos carried echoes of

Roscoe Mitchell
saxophoneb.1940
There was no escaping the potency of work-song "Libation for Mr. Brown: Bid Em In..." which recalls the inhumanity of slave auctions. There was pause for thought too when Roberts softly sang the lullaby "All The Pretty Horses," relating how wet-nurse slaves would breast-feed their masters' infants, leaving no milk for their own children. That African Americans are still navigating the history and legacy of slavery was underlined when Robert's explained that her parents chose the name Matana as it has no connection with the slave trade.
Roberts connected easily with the audience, sharing stories of her Irish ancestry, speaking to the connection between historically oppressed peoples and their spirit of perseverance and coaxing audience participation in mantra-like gospel-folk singalongs and chants. There was humor too, but the performance was diluted by numerous, slightly rambling anecdotes that took up too much of a disappointingly short set.
In these diversions, Roberts bemoaned the state of American politics, lumped Trump and Boris Johnson together, wondered why Madonna's "Like A Virgin" could get stuck in her head, sang Stevie Nick's "Landslide" (with a lengthy appreciation of the lyrics) and promised not to sing "Danny Boy,"to general reliefdespite Robert's grandmother's voice in her head suggesting just that.
Roberts found appreciative ears when she called out the American government for continuing to sell arms to Israel and branded the Israeli operation in Gaza as genocide and ethnic cleansing. There are not enough such brave voices in the world today, with most artists seeming reluctant to use their platform to call out BS and to inspire change. "We have a responsibility to stand up for others who cannot stand up for themselves," Roberts told the audience. "No justice... " the Chicagoan offered, to which the audience replied as one "No peace"a line that became a gentle chant.
The remarkable figure of Coincoin arose fleetingly as Roberts sang a snatch of the performance piece "Pov Piti": "I was born a child of the moon in the year of seventeen hundred and forty-two, the second daughter... qua qua qua qua qua coin coin..."but it lacked the ferocious, unsettling intensity of Robert's performance on Coin Coin Chapter One: Gens de Coleurs Libres (Constellation, 2011).
In conclusion, Roberts led a chant of the refrain "Live life out loud. Live life, stay proud." Fifty minutes felt like short change, even for a solo set, all the more so given the fragmented, skittish nature of this performance. Roberts is a major artist, undoubtedly, but tonight there just was not enough bang for your coin coin.
Tags
Comments
PREVIOUS / NEXT
Support All About Jazz
