Home » Jazz Articles » Extended Analysis » Red Nichols: Red Nichols: The Red Heads

Red Nichols: Red Nichols: The Red Heads

By Andrew J. Sammut
May 6, 2011
View read count

Red Nichols

The Red Heads

Jazz Oracle

2003

If you play on your own terms for small audiences without any recognition, you're a hero; if you do it while earning a steady paycheck and selling plenty of records, you're a sell-out. Or so it might seem for Ernest Loring "Red" Nichols (1905-1965): trumpeter, composer, bandleader, polarizing figure in American music and possibly the most well employed musician of the Jazz Age.

Red Nichols

b.1905

" data-original-title="" title="">Red Nichols' impeccable musicianship and keen business sense kept him working consistently in the theater, studio and on radio from the start of his career. At the same time his commercial success and singular style have made him a controversial figure, with many critics unwilling to acknowledge him as anything more than a mere popular musician. Nichols was rarely out of work, often leading the same personnel, and even playing the same tunes, under different names for different labels. While some may see his vast recorded output as the work of an opportunistic self-promoter, the records themselves reveal a technically assured musician attempting to say something musically unique, even if he was also trying to pay the rent.

As his Red Heads sessions demonstrate, Nichols was more than willing to channel his creativity through the popular styles of the day. Many of these sides feature dated (to modern ears) vocals from popular crooners of the time, most often Cliff "Ukulele Ike" Edwards (a.k.a. Jiminy Cricket of Disney's "Pinocchio"). Yet Nichols and his partners invigorate even the most banal pop ditty through engaging ensembles and scrappy solos.

"Poor Papa," an otherwise forgettable stick of Jazz Age bubble gum, gives us an idea of Nichols's approach to a pop song: a harmonically arresting introduction is followed by a tightly woven collective improvisation, setting up for a clarinet solo over simmering cymbals and upbeat piano punctuations. After a peppy interlude and nasal vocal, Nichols's powerful trumpet (heard to telling effect even on tinny acoustic surfaces) drives the band home to a smartly executed coda. Nichols' style and imagination energize most of these otherwise trite songs, with a few purely commercial recordings included for the sake of completists. The percolating "Sweet Child" features

Miff Mole

trombone
1898 - 1961

" data-original-title="" title="">Miff Mole's flip, facile trombone, and on "Five Foot Two, Eyes of Blue" Nichols crafts a witty solo commentary out of the 1920s anthem. "You Should See My Tootsie" shows off pianist

Arthur Schutt

b.1902

" data-original-title="" title="">Arthur Schutt and drummer

Vic Berton

b.1896

" data-original-title="" title="">Vic Berton locking in with playful counterpoint behind a cornball vocal, before

Jimmy Dorsey

composer / conductor
1904 - 1957

" data-original-title="" title="">Jimmy Dorsey's silvery alto sax adds measured cool to the atmosphere.

As these sessions also demonstrate, the Nichols style stands apart from the rhythmically aggressive, vocally inflected African American sounds of the time that influenced many white players and the course of jazz history. Harmonic subtlety, thematic variety and emotional detachment characterize Nichols band book originals such as "The Hurricane" and "Nervous Charlie." When the group strips down to trumpet/piano/drums for "Plenty Off Center," they offer a confident, clearly defined arrangement of several angular themes rather than an organic trio. "A Good Man is Hard to Find" finds the Red Heads spinning spirited yet thoughtful statements over a leisurely skipping beat. More inspired by European conservatories than New Orleans nightclubs, The Red Heads give the impression of a late 1920s "cool" school, especially daring at a time when "hot" and "jazz" were rarely separable.

Even more surprising is the Red Heads' approach to tunes associated with influential African American artists, such as

Jelly Roll Morton

piano
1890 - 1941

" data-original-title="" title="">Jelly Roll Morton's "Black Bottom Stomp" or

Louis Armstrong

trumpet and vocals
1901 - 1971

" data-original-title="" title="">Louis Armstrong's "Heebie Jeebies." The visceral drive and spontaneity of the more famous versions are replaced with an introverted, coordinated elegance. The Red Heads' softer attack and transparent lines gives these works a "chamber jazz" feel that is more restrained but just as sincere. Rather than stamping these recordings as the "white" versions of well-known classics, it's helpful to hear them as the work of intelligent, sensitive musicians making the material their own; as a definition of jazz, we could do a lot worse.

While early jazz aficionados will find ample historical interest here, curious listeners looking to explore the roads jazz did not take, or our hallowed American art music's early trysts with pop music, might find this set interesting. Alternate takes reveal the band experimenting and loosening up, and Reide Kaiser's liners notes are informative and well researched. Unfortunately recording techniques at Pathe (the label which originally released these sides) were fairly outdated even for their time, and even the engineering wizards at Jazz Oracle could only do so much to compensate. Dated vocals and poor sound aside, this is an expansive investigation into one fork in the road of jazz.

Tracks: CD1: Jimtown Blues; King Porter Stomp; I Wouldn't Be Where I Am If You Hadn't Gone Away; Flag That Train ; I'm "Gonna" Hang Around My Sugar; Five Foot Two, Eyes of Blue; Oh Lovey, Be Mine; Say, Who Is That Baby Doll; How She Loves Me Is Nobody's Business; The Lonesomest Girl in Town; Remember; Someone's Stolen My Sweet, Sweet Baby; Dreaming of a Castle in the Air; How Can You Look So Good?; Fallen Arches; Nervous Charlie Stomp; Headin' for Louisville; Dinah; Keep on Croonin' a Tune; Clap Hands, Here Comes Charley!; Spanish Shawl; No Man's Mama; Oh Lovely, Be Mine; Say, Who Is That Baby Doll. CD2: Sweet Child; I Want Somebody to Cheer Me Up; Sometime; Poor Papa; 'Tain't Cold; Hangover; Plenty Off Center; Trumpet Sobs; Wild and Foolish; Hi-Diddle-Diddle; Dynamite; Alabama Stomp; The Hurricane; Brown Sugar; Sunday; I Don't Mind Being All Alone; Meadowlark; I Never Knew What the Moonlight Could Do; Get With; Get a Load of This; I Want Somebody to Cheer Me Up; Hurricane; Sunday; I Don't Mind Being All Alone. CD3: I'm Tellin' the Birds-Tellin' the Bees; That's No Bargain; Heebie Jeebies; Black Bottom Stomp; How Could Red Riding Hood?; For My Sweetheart; Short and Sweet; Lonely Eyes; Since I Found You; I Know That You Know; Tell Me To-Night; Here or There; You Should See My Tootsie; A Good Man Is Hard to Find; Nothin' Does Does Like It Used to Do Do Do; Baltimore; Black Bottom Stomp; How Could Red Riding Hood?; Tell Me To-Night; Tell Me To-Night; Here or There; You Should See My Tootsie; You Should See My Tootsie; A Good Man Is Hard to Find; Nothin' Does Does Like It Used to Do Do Do; Baltimore.

Personnel: Red Nichols: trumpet; Miff Mole: trombone; Jimmy Dorsey: clarinet, saxophone; Arthur Schutt: piano; Vic Berton: drums; Joe Tarto: tuba; Eddie Lang: guitar; Dick McDonough: guitar; Joe Venuti: violin; Brad Gowans: trombone; Wingy Manone: cornet; others.

Learn more about our star rating system

Personnel

Red Nichols

Includes Red Nichols: trumpet; Miff Mole: trombone; Jimmy Dorsey: clarinet, saxophone; Arthur Schutt: piano; Vic Berton: drums; Joe Tarto: tuba; Eddie Lang: guitar; Dick McDonough: guitar; Joe Venuti: violin; Brad Gowans: trombone; Wingy Manone: cornet.

Album information

Title: Red Nichols: The Red Heads | Year Released: 2011 | Record Label: Jazz Oracle

PREVIOUS / NEXT

Salt Song
< Previous

Miho - Journey to the Mountain
Next >

Support All About Jazz

All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

Go Ad Free!

To maintain our platform while developing new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity, we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for as little as $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination vastly improves your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.