Home » Jazz Articles » Album Review » Henry Threadgill Ensemble: The Other One

Henry Threadgill Ensemble: The Other One

By Troy Dostert
July 11, 2023
View read count

Henry Threadgill Ensemble: The Other One

Now that Henry Threadgill has begun receiving the accolades he has long deserved—the Pulitzer Prize he won in 2016 for In for a Penny, In for a Pound (Pi Recordings, 2015) being just the most prominent example—it is impressive to find him still relentlessly stretching himself as a performer and composer. Since his first forays into the jazz avant-garde in the 1970s, the maverick multi-instrumentalist has always made music that challenges listeners in exciting ways, but it is his uncanny ability to keep finding new formulations for his art that is most stunning. Refusing to rest on his laurels, Threadgill's persistent quest for uncharted sonic frontiers continues unabated, and 2023's album, The Other One, is yet another noteworthy triumph.

After his pioneering trio work with

Fred Hopkins

bass
1947 - 1999

" data-original-title="" title="">Fred Hopkins and

Steve McCall

drums
b.1933

" data-original-title="" title="">Steve McCall in Air, Threadgill created much of his most compelling music with mid-sized ensembles. Whether with his Sextett in the 1980s on releases like Easily Slip into Another World (Arista/Novus, 1988) and Rag, Bush and All (Arista/Novus, 1989), or Very Very Circus in the 1990s, on Too Much Sugar for a Dime (Axiom, 1993) or Song Out of My Trees (Black Saint, 1993), Threadgill's penchant for creating unique harmonic possibilities amidst churning, often infectious rhythmic motifs was his trademark, and having at least a half-dozen colleagues in tow gave these projects their creative vitality. More recently, his releases by his Zooid group have tended to draw on a quintet format, as on 2021's Poof (Pi Recordings). All of which made Threadgill's turn toward a large-ensemble format in 2018 one of his most intriguing ventures. His group for that project, the curiously-titled 14 or 15 Kestra: Agg, created Dirt...and More Dirt (Pi, 2018), and it was invigorating to hear Threadgill's compositions make use of a wider palette (in this case, one that included two drummers and two pianists) to give voice to his expansive pieces. At first blush, The Other One would seem a related endeavor, with a twelve-member ensemble called into action (albeit one in which Threadgill serves only as composer and conductor). But more than any previous Threadgill recording, this release possesses much stronger classical resonances, and a correspondingly attenuated jazz language. Even so, there is more than enough stimulating music in its hour-long runtime to justify the praise it will no doubt receive.

The ensemble here is not without connections to Threadgill's earlier projects, as it includes

David Virelles

piano
b.1983

" data-original-title="" title="">David Virelles (piano),

Jose Davila

tuba

" data-original-title="" title="">Jose Davila (tuba),

Christopher Hoffman

cello
b.1978

" data-original-title="" title="">Christopher Hoffman (cello) and

Craig Weinrib

drums

" data-original-title="" title="">Craig Weinrib (percussion), all of whom have been present on recent Threadgill albums. But there is a notable absence, namely that of guitarist

Liberty Ellman

guitar

" data-original-title="" title="">Liberty Ellman, who has played a critical role in the rhythmic and melodic propensities of Threadgill's music since Up Popped the Two Lips (Pi, 2001). And with a strong string and woodwind section including a second cellist (

Mariel Roberts

cello

" data-original-title="" title="">Mariel Roberts), a violinist (

Sara Caswell

violin

" data-original-title="" title="">Sara Caswell), violist (

Stephanie Griffin

viola

" data-original-title="" title="">Stephanie Griffin) and two bassoonists (

Sara Schoenbeck

bassoon

" data-original-title="" title="">Sara Schoenbeck and

Adam Cordero

saxophone, alto
b.1999

" data-original-title="" title="">Adam Cordero), the ensemble has the fundamental character and sound of a plus-sized chamber group. Blues and jazz references emerge here and there, but they tend to be fugitive and fleeting—although certainly no less effective and memorable for that.

The album is comprised of a long composition, "Of Valence," which itself has three movements, two of which offer a number of relatively brief sections that bring smaller configurations of the ensemble to the forefront; Virelles gets an especially motion-filled five-minute solo opening during the first two sections of Movement I. And if the music is not quite as hard-hitting and rhythmically intoxicating as Threadgill's most well-known projects, there is something irresistible about hearing the bassoons and strings take on so much of the heavy lifting, particularly in their delicate interactions with Virelles. Expertly managing the negotiations between composed and improvised forms, these players are adeptly attuned to Threadgill's approach, and it shows in music that never fails to surprise and engage. And when the saxophones (

Alfredo Colón

saxophone

" data-original-title="" title="">Alfredo Colón,

Noah Becker

saxophone, tenor
b.1970

" data-original-title="" title="">Noah Becker, and

Peyton Pleninger

saxophone, tenor

" data-original-title="" title="">Peyton Pleninger) finally make their featured appearance in Sections 6A-7A with distinctively Latin- inflected overtones, the effect is especially transfixing. The gripping "Finale" sees the ensemble letting loose a bit more, with Virelles again producing a lot of the energy that Weinrib adroitly matches with a bouncing tempo.

Movement III offers similar pleasures, whether it is the fascinating harmonies beneath Caswell and Becker (the latter on clarinet) during Sections 12-12B or the complex rhythmic dynamism supporting the saxophones in Section 14, with Davila's tuba providing plenty of bass-register heft. But the highlight of the composition is really Movement II, where Threadgill's imagination soars. What begins as a gently searching string segment with Caswell, Griffin and Roberts in close rapport evolves into something much more unusual, as electronics connected to Weinrib's cymbals announce a transition into an unsettled space, with the other instruments gradually finding their way into an abrasive, improvised maelstrom, before giving way to other more oblique nuances and possibilities. But unlike the more episodic delights of the rest of the album, this is a sustained, sixteen-minute extravaganza of uninterrupted music, with the musicians at their most animated. And much like Threadgill's imposing body of work as a whole, there is always a subtle beauty to be found amidst the tumult.

Learn more about our star rating system

Track Listing

Movement I: Sections 1-2; Section 3; Sections 4-4A; Sections 5-6; Sections 6A-7A; Sections 8-8A; Sections 9-11; Section 11 (Trapset Interlude); Finale; Movement II; Movement III: Section 11A; Sections 12-12B; Section 12B (Violin Interlude); Section 13; Section 14; Section 15; Section 16; Section 17; Finale.

Personnel

Henry Threadgill

woodwinds

David Virelles

piano

Alfredo Colón

saxophone

Noah Becker

saxophone, tenor

Peyton Pleninger

saxophone, tenor

Sara Caswell

violin

Stephanie Griffin

viola

Christopher Hoffman

cello

Mariel Roberts

cello

Jose Davila

tuba

Sara Schoenbeck

bassoon

Adam Cordero

saxophone, alto

Craig Weinrib

drums

Additional Instrumentation

Henry Threadgill: conductor; Noah Becker: alto sax, clarinet; Jose Davila: tuba.

Album information

Title: The Other One | Year Released: 2023 | Record Label: Pi Recordings

PREVIOUS / NEXT

Rochester International Jazz Festiva...
< Previous

Times
Next >

Support All About Jazz

All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made "AAJ" one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.

Go Ad Free!

To maintain our platform while developing new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity, we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for as little as $20 and in return, we'll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination vastly improves your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.