There have been popular views by certain so-called experts that seem to have been accepted as dogma, the term "less is more" being one of them. However, as in any subject from sports to politics to science to religion, every pundit has an equal who has a contrary opinion. I, for one, am bothered by some of these views and not only have a contrary view of them but feel many are either misleading, questionable, or downright wrong.

Now I realize that I'm going to take some heat for this. And I'll be offending some who are considered icons in the music industry. That fact actually bothers me even more because these supposed experts who are in demand due to some modicum of fame are really doing a disservice to the young musicians looking up to them. In fact, I suppose this article is meant as much as an admonishment and caveat for them as it is for debunking the "less is more" theory.

Maybe I'll even get some hate mail. Or maybe I'll just be ignored. I have no idea what the repercussions will be but I've never been one to worry about that. I've always spoken my mind and espoused what I sincerely felt was the truth. Of course, sometimes it is only an opinion, but it is perceived as the truth. In any event, I am and always have been prepared to face any consequences for speaking my mind. Even if you don't agree with me, I am sure you will find credibility in my opinion and it will give you something to think about.

I'm a drummer so I will continue from this point on from a drummer's perspective, especially since this so-called axiom of the music industry is usually aimed at drummers, but what I am saying applies to all instruments. I'm also known as a jazz musician, which is where my heart is, so I will also relate what I'm saying from a jazz perspective. Again, it applies to all styles of music.

This phrase, "less is more," not only really irks me but I believe it has caused the lack of development in young musicians... especially drummers. What inspiration does it give? What type of motivation will a young drummer have to spend time developing advanced technique and art if he or she should play simply? Why work hard in the practice room on advanced reading, coordination, and technical ability when someone is telling you to play a simple backbeat? Instead of being told it is better to play less, these young musicians should be taught to play for the music. Instead of a producer or bandleader saying to play less, it would be better to say "this song requires a simple backbeat" instead of giving the impression that playing less is the commendable thing and should be strived for in all situations.

I've worked with some great musicians and not one of them ever asked me to play less. In fact, they always wanted me to play more. Phrases like "play out" and "develop it" and "go for it" come to my memory. The great organist